All for One, One for ...

Why can’t Europe’s leaders agree about Europe? Mujtaba Rahman on their disunity in facing the continent’s biggest political and security problems. Brought to you by [The Oslo Freedom Forum]( Recently at The Signal: Steven Cook on [what the U.S. hold on sending bombs to Israel means for the two countries’ relationship](. … Today: Why can’t Europe’s leaders agree about Europe? Mujtaba Rahman on their disunity in facing the continent’s biggest political and security problems. … Also: Laurent Dubois on crisis in Haiti. … Subscribe to The Signal? Share with a friend. … Sent to you? Sign up [here](. The 27 Musketeers Sir John Gilbert Right after Russian forces invaded Ukraine in February 2022, the member states of the European Union moved to [impose heavy sanctions on Moscow]( and [coordinate financial and military support for Kyiv](. They seized the European assets belonging to cronies of Russia’s President Vladimir Putin. And they almost completely cut off imports of Russian oil and gas, which for decades had been critical sources of energy for most of the continent. Two years later, though, its leaders are betraying clashing views on the war and other key strategic issues. In a speech at the Sorbonne on April 24, France’s President Emanuel Macron said he stood by his suggestion earlier this year that European soldiers might end up having to fight in Ukraine to keep Russia from winning. Yet when Macron first mentioned the idea, Germany’s Chancellor Olaf Scholz immediately rejected it—and has continued to. Meanwhile, in mid-April, Scholz took a delegation of German CEOs to Beijing, looking to boost trade ties with the People’s Republic and keep Chinese markets open to German exports. Three weeks later, when the Chinese Communist Party’s General Secretary Xi Jinping visited Macron in Paris, Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission, attended their meeting—only to warn Xi about what she sees as an unacceptable [surge in low-priced Chinese exports]( into European markets. Security, trade—why do Europe’s leaders seem so far apart on the most pressing issues they’re confronting together? Mujtaba Rahman is the London-based managing director for Europe at the New York–based Eurasia Group, a global political-risk consultancy, and a former economist for the European Commission and the U.K. Treasury. In Rahman’s view, European unity is a paradox: Since Russia’s attack, Europe’s leaders have worked together on common projects that previous heads of state had never managed. And yet systemic problems, along with domestic political pressures, have held them back from building a shared strategy for the European Union’s foreign policy and security. Their new cooperation—whether on economic sanctions, finances, or the potential expansion of the EU—is making Brussels a more powerful actor globally. But the EU’s member states are still pursuing their own security strategies and foreign policies—and they won’t yield any power over them that they don’t have to. At the same time, Rahman says, individual European leaders are too preoccupied with political challenges in their countries to think much about—let alone develop—long-term European strategies. All of which is creating a growing tension between the continent’s global economic power and its lack of political coherence. [Read on]( Advertisement From Mujtaba Rahman at The Signal: “There’s no shared European perspective on security. The continent’s leaders recognize that the world is more dangerous, that Europe needs to do more geopolitically, and that spending on security at the EU level has to increase. But that’s where the consensus ends.” “There’s no buy-in for Macron’s idea about strategic autonomy. Almost no one is willing to accept it. I don’t see Germany being interested in living in a world where they rely on French nuclear weapons for their security. I also don’t see Germany developing its own nuclear weapons. For the imaginable future—even a variation in which Trump is the U.S. president again—Europeans are going to attempt to work with the U.S. administration for security.” “Europe struggles—and will likely continue to struggle—to exert geopolitical power that corresponds to its economic power. The confused debate among European capitals on what to do about Trump is just one example They’re unable to think strategically and coherently in response to some of these critical questions they’re facing, which are going to need answers—soon.” [Members can access the full conversation here]( FROM THE FILES A Series of Violent Events Marco Bianchetti On May 23, an armed gang attacked a U.S. Christian missionary group in Haiti, where the state has mostly stopped functioning, killing the group’s Haitian director and a married American missionary couple. Gangs now mostly run the country, having gradually taken control since the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse. That was in July 2021. A month later, Laurent Dubois explored the political dynamics that led up to the assassination. As Dubois sees it, the government has often lacked legitimacy in Haiti, mainly for having often represented outside interests—notably American interests. In the next few days, about 2,500 Kenyan police officers are expected to arrive in Haiti to try to restore order. Dubois explains the historical background to that challenge. [Read on]( Join The Signal—to support our independent current-affairs coverage, explore our archive, and unlock our full conversations with hundreds of contributors: [Become a member]( Coming soon: Robert Hamilton on what Russia's recent battlefield gains mean for the war in Ukraine … Subscribe to The Signal? Share with a friend. Sent to you? Sign up [here](. This email address is unmonitored. Please send questions or comments [here](mailto:concierge@thesgnl.com). To advertise with The Signal, inquire [here](mailto:advertise@thesgnl.com). Add us to your [address book](mailto:newsletter@thesgnl.com). Unsubscribe [here](. © 2024 [unsubscribe](