The Global Identity Crisis: The Galli Report

Also: What We Think We Know | Understanding Lines | Cheap Grace Today: The Galli Report | [View online]( [Give Now]( Advertisement [The Galli Report]( [Home]( [Podcast]( [Subscribe]( Friday, February 15, 2019 The Global Identity Crisis I’ve been intrigued by Francis Fukuyama for some time. He made a big splash back in the day with his The End of History, which most misunderstood. He’s a “big idea” thinker, the type I’m a sucker for—attempting to understand all the strands of our times in terms of one, coherent, controlling theme. I recognize from the beginning that this really isn’t possible, but big ideas do have a way of helping us understand a great deal. The intro to [a review of his latest book,]( which is already on my Kindle, does as good a job as any in summarizing his views and teasing one to read not only the review (a long read well worth it) but also his book: Dignity, recognition, esteem, respect, and the resentment that arises when they are not accorded—these are the themes of Francis Fukuyama’s new book. Like many political commentators, he was surprised by the results of two elections in 2016: the victories for Brexit and Donald Trump. To understand them, he sought a “master concept,” something that would explain not only these results, but also the many other political movements of this decade, from the rise of populism around the globe to #MeToo and campus protests in America. In [Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment](, he proposes “identity,” a concept that grows “out of a distinction between one’s true inner self and an outer world of social rules and norms that does not adequately recognize that inner self’s worth or dignity.” … His framing of our present crisis as one of identity politics—which he understands broadly enough to encompass right-wing as well as left-wing versions, the international scene as well as domestic conflicts—is lucid and insightful. What We Think We Know As I have discovered especially in editorial writing, one has to not only take into account the facts but what readers imagine the facts are—which are often massively wrong. That’s why I warmed [to this review of a book]( that makes that point in spades. As the reviewer noted: Producing reactions of chuckles, indignation, anger, and unseeming self-indulgent pride, Duffy takes me on a journey of the sometimes unbelievably large divergence between the state of the world and our polled beliefs about the world. And … we’re almost always talking about objective, uncontroversial measures of things we keep pretty good track of: wealth inequality, share of immigrants in society, medically defined obesity, number of Facebook accounts, murder and unemployment rates. On subject after subject, people guess the most outlandish things: almost 80% of Britons believed that the number of deaths from terrorist attacks between 2002 and 2016 were more or about the same as 1985–2000, when the actual number was a reduction of 81% (p. 131)…. More examples abound. An enjoyable if somewhat troubling read! Understanding Lines Speaking of misperceptions—here’s an everyday one. Take [this example from John Cook]( of tellers serving customers at a bank: “Suppose a small bank has only one teller. Customers take an average of 10 minutes to serve and they arrive at the rate of 5.8 per hour. What will the expected waiting time be? What happens if you add another teller? “We assume customer arrivals and customer service times are random (details later). With only one teller, customers will have to wait nearly five hours on average before they are served.” Five hours?! I would not have guessed anywhere close to that, would you? Now, add a second teller into the mix. How long is the average wait now? 2.5 hours? 1 hour? According to Cook, much lower than that: “But if you add a second teller, the average waiting time is not just cut in half; it goes down to about 3 minutes. The waiting time is reduced by a factor of 93x.” I don’t claim to understand what’s going on but, like the author of [this article on queuing theory,]( I was amazed. Cheap Grace Today Nadia Bolz-Weber has made a big splash as a “foul-mouthed, tattoo-festooned recovering alcoholic and former stand-up comic who founded Denver’s House for All Sinners and Saints, a progressive Lutheran congregation that has become known as a haven for ex-evangelicals and other religious or not-so-religious misfits.” Like most extremists, she has had bursts of insights about the gospel, but in the end she’s peddling a gospel without contrition and genuine absolution. Wesley Hill of Trinity School of Ministry does a marvelous job of [reviewing the strengths and weakness of her latest book,]( as well as prompting us traditionalists to a little self-examination regarding our own sins. Grace and peace, [Mark Galli] [Mark Galli] [Mark Galli](mailto:GalliReport@christianitytoday.com) Editor-in-Chief, Christianity Today Advertisement More from Christianity Today [Origins Opinion Surveys Evolve from ‘How’ to ‘Who’]( Research [Origins Opinion Surveys Evolve from ‘How’ to ‘Who’]( Many Christians affirm evolution once researchers leave room for God's role in it. Nadia Whitehead [Read More]( [All Loves Excelling: How Romance Inspired Charles Wesley’s View of God]( [Christian History]( [All Loves Excelling: How Romance Inspired Charles Wesley’s View of God]( The famous hymn-writer’s understanding of divine love was reflected in his mortal marriage. Jeffrey W. Barbeau [Read More]( [No, Millennials Aren’t Killing Evangelism]( [Quick to Listen]( [No, Millennials Aren’t Killing Evangelism]( But if you’re hesitant about sharing the gospel in the 21st century, here's what you need to know about effectively reaching people for Christ. Morgan Lee [Read More]( [View All of our Latest]( In the magazine [January/February]( [Book Awards]( [Christianity Today’s 2019 Book Awards]( Our picks for the books most likely to shape evangelical life, thought, and culture. [Building on the Black Church’s Bible Legacy]( [Can Anger at God Be Righteous?]( [View Full Issue]( [Subscribe Now]( Related Newsletters [CT Books]( Each issue contains up-to-date, insightful information about today’s culture, plus analysis of books important to the evangelical thinker. [Sign Up Now]( [Christianity Today Connection]( Get the inside story with this official newsletter of the global media ministry. [Sign Up Now]( Advertisement Follow Us: [Follow on Facebook]( [Follow on Twitter]( [RSS]( Want to stay informed but a little short on free time? Try The Galli Report, a weekly newsletter giving you 5 must-read articles for thought leaders handpicked by CT Editor Mark Galli. The Galli Report Delivered free via email to subscribers Weekly. [Subscribe]( to this newsletter. You are currently subscribed as {EMAIL}. [Subscribe]( to more newsletters like this. Manage your [email preferences]( or [unsubscribe](. Copyright ©2019 Christianity Today 465 Gundersen Drive, Carol Stream, IL 60188 All rights reserved. [Privacy Policy]( | [Advertise]( | [Subscribe to CT]( | [Give Now]( Christianity Today is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.